Ruins In The Wake Of The Tsunami
For activists and radicals, elections are like weather. They can be quite impactful, but they’re also totally outside of our hands. A hurricane bursts the levees and drowns a minority community. A wet winter restores depleted snowpacks and saves the summer harvest. It would be absurd to not have opinions on the weather, or to not make preparations, but just as absurd to pretend that our words (or votes) can overrule the wind cycles and stop a specific storm. Perhaps someone in a super PAC somewhere has access to the relevant space lasers, but we do not. Our capabilities are great, but they lie elsewhere.
This clarity on elections, I believe, has always left anarchists unusually capable of calling balls and strikes, as we feel no pull to build or maintain some sort of broad public narrative or team morale. Nor do we have to pretend that the masses are on our side, and that it’s strategic for politicians to position themselves closer to us. Many heinous desires are popular, and many moral truths are despised. It has always been thus.
Liberalism is not a party bloc but an ideology that underpins electoralism itself, and one must be careful to not instinctively replicate electoralist thinking in ostensible opposition to liberalism, strategizing as though we were just another minor party contesting for vote share. There’s an eternal tendency by baby anarchists to treat “not voting” as functionally another candidate to campaign for, and this misses the entire point about the inefficiency of electoralism.
It’s not just silly to deny any positives to liberals winning more seats than fascists, it’s the kind of partisan hackery and chasing of narrative influence that electoralism encourages. All other things equal, as a bare fact it is obviously better for 99% Hitler to win an election than 100% Hitler, and refusing to acknowledge that is just empty posturing about virtue. If 10 million people are going to die in a holocaust, a 1% improvement is 100,000 lives saved. When a single cop stumbles and shoots himself in the dick at a protest, that doesn’t change the institutional power of the police, or change the massive weight of their ongoing atrocities, but still, 99 cops left alive instead of 100 cops is an objectively better situation. It may be on the margins, there may be a fuckload of cops still actively beating us, there may be more complex and contingent implications, but we’re allowed to take the W. Laughing at the single dying cop doesn’t mean lessening our resolve to fight the vast horrors still aligned against us.
At the same time, any honest accounting of the strategic landscape has to cash out in something other than a scalar, a single number. The world is not merely good or bad on a single dimension, a single spectrum, like seats won in a legislature. Rather, like the weather, every electoral development inflicts new costs, opens new opportunities, and poses new dangers.
For many that are invested in the spectacle of the democratic arena, the overwhelming sweep of liberals in the 2026 US midterms is an opportunity to echo and intone a “vibe shift” into being, to shape, with each post, the contours of new national narratives in the brains of other players. For others, who conceptualize themselves as members of a faction called “the left”, the jubilance of the libs is a personal affront and sets off every warning siren. Um, excuse me, don’t you know that the US empire was founded on genocide and slavery and remains an engine of anti-black settler-colonial extractivism, exploitation, and warmongering, with liberalism just another face of the same fascist beast? Yes, of course. Who the fuck doesn’t know that?
We’re in a safe room – there’s none of those weird non-anarchists about – so let’s put aside the showy proclamations and get down to evaluating the object level.
The biggest concern of every anarchist I know is that this will herald a broad wipeout of radical struggle in the US.
First-time voters in 2026 were born in 2008, fittingly the last blue wave in the US, when Obama’s election served as a mass-extinction event across activist and radical spaces. The last vapors of the counterglobalization movement lingered until the G20 summit in Pittsburgh – and anarchists mobilized around Bash Back and the murder of Oscar Grant – but milieus in every city were visibly depleted by the scourge of HOPE. (Surprisingly, the contingent who marched in the celebrations of Obama’s inauguration as “Hope Bloc” failed to redirect those libs towards revolution.) Within three days of taking office, Obama murdered a family in a drone strike, but a surprisingly vast number of people who had been mobilized by Bush went home to brunch. Radical subcultural spaces and the big activist coalitions that had mobilized against Bush went into decline. For a few years the air grew noticeably cold and thin. It’s almost impossible to convey how depressing this time was.
One signpost of how fucked everything got is that it saw the real modern birth of the “nihilism” meme by a small circle in the Bay (themselves cribbing from a couple british marxists and some kids in Athens). This Berkeley clique picked fights with insurrectionary anarchists, loudly proclaiming that struggle was over and we should permanently retreat to commune land projects. Surprising no one, the proclaimed death of cringe carelord “strugglismo” didn’t last, and these “nihilists” ended up marginalized to the sidelines, sneering at everyone going out to fight for black lives in the Ferguson uprising, before losing their shit about the resurgence of antifascism. Still, for a few years such burnouts (without the backbone to fully leave) fed off the contraction of the radical scene and the broad despair that accompanied it.
I share concerns that we’re on the verge of a similar winter. We love to grouse about people going back to brunch as foul-weather comrades with no depth of commitment to the Beautiful Idea, liberals who only rise and pick up the black flag out of convenience when they stop hearing the lullabies of democracy. And with every lib victory my heart is broken anew by a few individuals I had hoped would last. But the comforting reassurance that we’re better off without them, reinvigorated by the purity of those who remain, simply does not bear out. Anarchism remains structurally a parasitic movement. We overwhelmingly recruit from outraged leftist activists. We have almost no other recruitment channels, and almost all other avenues attempted have pulled an even higher fraction of disruptive abusers, fascists, wingnuts and scumfucks. Every anarchist that lasts was always a bleeding heart of some stripe, and like it or not, the default position of naive bleeding hearts in our society is left-liberalism.
While they were desperate, there was ground to be gained in getting liberals to start to think about the raw power dynamics of the state before the election, to start to see the inherent corrupting logic of centralization and the unsustainability of internal checks and balances. But one significant downside of massive Democratic majorities in the Senate and the House is that it has re-centralized the imaginary of resistance. Everything is going to be trials and committee maneuverings, suffocating attention to street-level resistance. The scales are firmly back over most liberal eyes.
And, of course, this doesn’t just mean less new blood flowing into our projects, it also means a freer hand for state repression. There is no season in which we are not brutalized, raided, and imprisoned, but there are times when that garners sympathetic coverage in alt weeklies and handwringing in DA offices… and times when it does not.
This is not to say, of course, that work shouldn’t be done to leverage whatever connections we have in media and electoral spaces to get freeing the Prairieland folks, the Minneapolis 15, etc perceived as urgent, mandated, and possible in the election’s aftermath. The odds aren’t great, but we usually can’t afford to get too precious around the endless humiliation ritual of legal defense; I’d suck a politician’s dick if it got my friends out of prison and back in the fight. By all means, let’s keep the pressure on and see if we can sneak any messaging into the liberal spectacle.
But the issue isn’t just that we’ll probably have even less normie liberal attention and sympathy in the coming years, it’s also that we ourselves will be targets of their revenge. Despite attempts to appropriate “antifascism” from anarchists (not just by liberals but also by “big tent” leftists who detested antifa as counterproductive wreckers before Trump), its core planks and analyses repeatedly proved indigestible, and liberals instead coalesced around “Countering Violent Extremism.”
The CVE framework is designed to comfort liberals by equating anarchists and fascists, and there’s no question that liberals will frame their coming trials and prosecutions as a matter of restoring “the rule of law.” Every intonation of that phrase a comforting lullaby to get libs to shut their eyes once again to everything Trump laid bare about the nature of the state (and law). Liberals can’t win in a direct confrontation with our ideas, so they inevitably go at us sideways. There’s good odds the next few years will be a boot reading, “Trump is an anarchist,” repeatedly stomping on our faces.
Listen to prominent liberal pundits – from Hasan Piker to Jamelle Bouie to Ezra Klein to Matthew Yglesias – and it’s stark how frequently they irately bring up anarchist ideas that slipped into public circulation around the 2020 uprising. It’s almost compulsive how they feel the need to reassert that appropriated reformist pablum like merely Abolishing The Police is insane and (interchangeably) “polls poorly.” We got them spooked. And just as they have no capacity to grapple with what the state actually is, much less defend it, they have no capacity to respond to the intellectual content of anarchism. So they just forcibly reiterate with a threatening tone in their voice that any creeping influence of ours is beyond the Overton Window. If Trump gets replaced by a Democrat President (rather than Tucker Carlson or whatever), and these liberals finally acquire more power than words, do you think they won’t ruthlessly apply such against us?
Meanwhile, let’s be frank, many on the Left have only ever encountered weak and even laughable versions of our ideas, sliced out of relevant context and presented in shallow ways by figures leeching from our cultural capital. We let vapid nonprofit workers on Instagram control the presentation of prison abolition, and as a result there will be a million people echoing “I don’t truck with that abolitionist stuff because I don’t actually think we can rely on everyone being nice if they get their basic needs met,” for the rest of their lives. Similarly, if the only criticism of electoralism they ever heard was that the Democrats and the Republicans are somehow exactly identical, it won’t take much to send them bitterly griping that anarchists are willfully ignorant and should not be listened to.
Much of the convulsion of relief around the electoral success of the Democrats has taken the narrative form of a return to “normality” and a permanent shutting out of fringe, weird, extremists. “Trust The Science” turns into a defense of centralized academic institutions. Paeans to “Democracy” turn into hostility to subcultural spaces of diverse expertise or prefiguration. And among all this is the long-lurking visceral hatred of the internet. Remember the good old days of vetted centralized media when you couldn’t see the nazis (or the anarchists)? When no one could talk back to you?
Of course social media technologies are specifically structured in ways that don’t give people substantive or fluid options in audience, thus creating constant conflict or at least the omnipresent threat of interactions from unchosen audiences, and this is the source of the acrimony and rage, not the fucking decentralization of voice. But liberal political and media elites are of one and the same mind on despising the internet, even more so than in the days of Indymedia. Now that they feel electoral tailwinds and the taste of historical mandate, they will return to worshiping the centralizing, moderating, dulling dystopia of “democracy” – unwilling to imagine it inevitably kicking their teeth in again.
Does anyone honestly think that a Democratic presidency will revoke the terrorist proscription of NoBlogs, much less institute any semblance of lasting protections to stop such a thing from happening again? Of course not. The full-throated attack on the internet visible in Burnham’s UK and Carney’s Canada will almost certainly be replicated within the US.
And, as we’ve seen, most leftists – so soured on the internet in sweeping terms – will not put up much of a fight. Social media bans for children. National ID to log online. Nationalization and moats once the AI infosec collapse gets a real crisis moment. The odds are we’re going to lose a lot more of the internet before it gets painstakingly rebuilt from the grassroots.
It seems unlikely that the anarchist movement will overall step up to the challenge. Beyond the exhaustion of a decade of fascist ascension, many have come to mask despair with disdain towards the internet. Rather than recognizing the abandonment of early projects like Indymedia and general anarchist standoffishness toward the internet as one of the strategic mistakes that got us into this mess, we’re seeing a widespread doubling down on the mistake. The collapse of NoBlogs has been widely read as not proof that we need more robust decentralized anarchist infrastructure and more attention to our tools, but somehow as legitimization for the same failed strategies of performative unplugging. We’re just gonna ride bikes and throw pebbles at windows to schedule meetings and pass along critical alerts. As if cargo-cult cosplay reenactments will by themselves bring back the robust social milieus of 90s punk and the counter-globalization movement. Real militants don’t need complex ecosystems of social and technical infrastructure, they just magically happen to meet one another in the dead of night when two of them try to burn down the same datacenter. Or so I hear.
I’m pissy about this, clearly. There’s probably another essay in me less snarkily and more systematically tearing apart “abandon the internet” discourse, and lots of love to those anarchists nevertheless passionately working on a variety of infrastructural projects. But with the winds once again blowing in a defeatist direction within anarchist spaces, it’s hard not to predict a nasty collision of all these weather patterns across liberals, leftists, and anarchists.
It’s almost possible to see this retreat as a preemptive embrace of the activist contraction that follows the electoral cycle, but of course the fatigue felt across the US anarchist movement, and the ideological evaluations of strategy, and the fascist administration’s fixation on destroying us have separate roots. If the coming downturn is particularly rough, newer generations will collapse the actual multicausal dynamics to a single story.
This is the other great danger of electoral narratives: they cover up the contingent complexity of history.
Even the language of “wave” implies a kind of cyclical periodicity: sure the conservatives were up, but just as surely the liberals return to power. How silly of the fascists to think they had a chance to seize permanent power and slaughter all the judges (as Vance’s theorist Yarvin encouraged). And if the fascists were silly to think that they had a shot at permanently ending the Republic and jolting the lumbering behemoth of the US into a permanent break, how silly must be those radicals who took them seriously and exhaustively counter-mobilized against them for a decade.
Why didn’t those silly radicals who picked up lasting injuries, many who were literally fucking murdered, while disrupting and dismantling the street wing of the fascist movement realize they only ever needed to vote harder.
The liberal institutions happened to (mostly) survive, so of course they were always going to survive. The system worked, as it will always work. Don’t worry your pretty head about how messy everything was, how weak liberal “checks and balances” proved to be, how easily the tissue paper tore. And definitely pay no mind to the endless fucking work, the immense genius and dedication by countless people, that was applied against the fascists outside of the liberal system.
It is, of course, good that the allies won World War II rather than the Axis, but we all know the cost of that victory: the anarchists in the maquis and other resistance movements were erased from mainstream history. The hundreds of thousands killed trying to head off the beast in Spain are spurned in death rather than apologized to, because there’s no awareness of what was lost by failing to stand with them. History, we are always told, could only ever go one way. And there’s nothing worse than being a premature antifascist.
Marxists – being just another species of liberal – love nothing more than erasing the complex contingency of history because they cannot abide individual agency and responsibility. Why did you losers waste your lives on campaigns and actions that cannot be reported publicly when the overall outcome was foreordained? Do you really think the fascists were ever going to get any further than they did? The party was always destined to win.
Conjoin this with the liberal desire to turn the corner, to get back to brunch, and all memory of the threat that the fascists posed at various points will be forgotten, and with it all memory of the threat that we posed at various points.
This may be some esoteric lore, but I’ve just learned that in 2020, a militant nationwide uprising did, in fact, occur. I’m told it was a big oopsie woopsie for Democrat messaging and the rogue party consultants responsible are being dealt with. 53% of Americans supported burning police precincts? Don’t be silly. Where’d you ever hear that?
In 2017, when Trump ordered the Muslim ban upon taking office, cops on the ground scoffed to lawyers and congressmen that they didn’t care about countervailing court orders, they took their orders only from the President, their guy. The liberal system actually almost died that week. It really honestly could have. It wouldn’t have taken much lining up for Trump to have realized he had the momentum and the support of the thugs with guns, and he could just bypass and erase the rest of the state apparatus. There were a dozen moments like that over the last decade. But there will be no accounting for them. The scales are firmly back over liberal eyes. By the time that President Tucker Carlson or whatever rolls around there will be no memory left for them to learn from.
I don’t know how to save this history, all this knowledge and experience, while it’s being pulled out with the tide, but we should try as best we can.
The crises keep coming faster and faster – we used to call this “the social singularity” – and when we’re done hemorrhaging comrades, licking our wounds, lying to ourselves, and infighting, there will come another wave of radicalization. It’s imperative that we correct those coming newbies about the actual space of possibility.